which pearl jam drummer you guys prefer?

screamkevin

New member
I prefer Abruzzese. I thought he got a really raw deal the way he got fired from PJ. Check out his stuff with Green Romance Orchestra, it's really cool. He's an awesome drummer. Cameron is really amazing, though.
 

tabbott23

New member
check out zak starkey playing with pearl jam and the healers on the track 'fortunate son' live in australia. lovely groove!
 

racefan33

New member
I would have to go with Abruzze.

I'm a groove guy and Irons is groove guy but to the extreme, he's all meat and potatoes with no entrees or dessert.

Cameron is solid but doesn't have the panache that Abruzze has. Pearl Jam is a really good band that is a perfect slot for a drummer that can add some extra flavors and I think that Abruzze is the best at that.
 

King J

New member
No doubt that Matt is da King of Kings. Both technically and musically. No wonder why 'Temple of the Dog' asked him at that time ... If you don't remember that was a sort of one time thing done in honor of Andy Wood, done by Chris Cornell, Eddie Vedder, Matt Cameron, Stone Gossard, Jeff Ament and Mike McCready...best symbiosis ever between Soundgarden and Pearl Jam
 

DrumHead15

New member
Dave Abruzzese, I agree with screaming kevin. I love his playing. Dave got the shaft with PJ. I stopped buying their stuff then as well, I really think they went downhill then. They lost a great deal of respect.
 

Dale

New member
grohl":3o8dm2dc said:
dave abruzzese.jack irons our matt cameron?
personaly my favorit is matt cameron
I am a fan of Matt Cameron with Soundgarden. I've never heard him with Pearl Jam so cannot comment.

I absolutely hated Dave Abruzzese's playing. I don't often hate what I hear a drummer do. But I sure hated his playing. And seeing him destroy their MTV Live Unplugged performance just got underneath my fingernails like bamboo. Totally inappropriate drumming in every which way I can think of. That they sacked him was good IMO.

On record, my favourite Pearl Jam drumming is the very first eponymous CD. I can't remember the drummer's name, but I sure remember the perfectly loose and slippery grooves he provided.

But my favourite Pearl Jam drummer only recorded some live clips. Matt Chamberlain. He's a very fine drummer indeed.
 

drumsmith1

New member
I really like Camerons playing with Soundgarden, but I would have to say Abruzzese fit Pearl Jam the best. They're first cd was by far the best one they put out.
 

endorser

New member
Dave all the way. Matt is awesome but not for Pearl Jam. I'd like to see him playing a Tony Williams style jazz gig
 

downshifter99

New member
Dave Abruuzese with Pearl Jam
Matt Cameron with sound Garden

Matt's awesome but pearl jam's no-where near Sound Garden so,therefore matt is limited.
 

Go Champale

New member
Cameron plays the Cameron parts great and some of them are really cool. But if anyone has listened to any of the recent PJ live discs, Cameron doesn't do the Abbruzzese parts justice.
I totally get the "putting his stamp" on the parts, but some of the setups should be kept the same.
i would have liked to hear more Matt Chamberlain stuff.
Dave Krusen the original drummer wrote some great parts for their best record and for that he gets big props from me.
I liked Jack Irons stuff with Eleven better than his PJ stuff anyway.

But I would take Cameron on my team anyday.....
 

Brento

New member
My god hands down Dave Abbruzzese.. He's king!! The songs haven't sounded the same since.. LONG LIVE DAVE ABBRUZZESE!!! hahahaha
 

Dale

New member
drumsmith1":3pmq9wzz said:
I really like Camerons playing with Soundgarden, but I would have to say Abruzzese fit Pearl Jam the best. They're first cd was by far the best one they put out.
Dave is not on their first CD. They sacked the drummer on the first CD after recording it. For reasons unknown. I heard he was a negative influence on the band.
 

m

New member
Dale":v2lnffod said:
But my favourite Pearl Jam drummer only recorded some live clips. Matt Chamberlain. He's a very fine drummer indeed.
I don't care for PJ one little bit, but I'd always thought Matt Chamberlin had something to do with them early on-
was beginning to think I'd dreamed it up.
Guess it's true though~

That guy is a machine! I've had to learn a few of his Tori Amos parts-
he's quite a tasteful composer
 

Call me Gideon

New member
I have to say that I pretty much stopped listening to Pearl Jam after Vitalogy but Ive heard the singles that theyve put out since. I loved Matt in Soundgarden but for PJ Id have to go with Dave.
 
Top